| 1871 – 1874 | James J Riley |
| 1875 – 1876 | James Vincent McCarthy |
| 1877 | Donald Beatson |
| 1878 – 1879 | James Vincent McCarthy |
| 1880 – 1882 | Alfred Colless |
| 1883 – 1884 | George Brian Besley |
| 1885 | James Evans |
| 1886 – 1888 | Michael Long |
| 1889 – 1890 | Thomas Richard Smith |
| Feb – May 1891 | Arthur Winborne Stephen |
| May 1891 – Oct 1891 | Michael Long |
| Oct 1891-1894 | Arthur William Nepean Judges |
| 1895 – 1897 | William Fulton |
| Feb 1898 – Oct 1898 | Alfred E E V Reid |
| Oct 1898 – Feb 1899 | William Player |
| 1899 | Michael Long |
| 1900 – Mar 1901 | William Player |
| Mar 1901 – 1902 | Frederick Daniel Woodriff |
| 1903 – May 1906 | Michael Long |
| May 1906 – 1907 | Frederick Mortimer Vine |
| 1908 | Dr Frederick Charles Higgins |
| 1909 – 1910 | Henry James Fulton Neale |
| 1911 – 1915 | Thomas Jones |
| 1916 – 1917 | David Fitch |
| 1918 | Patrick Joseph Quinn |
| 1919 | Thomas Jones |
| 1920 | David Fitch |
| 1921 – 1922 | John Adams |
| 1923 -1925 | David Fitch |
| 1926 | John Junius Price |
| 1927 – 1929 | Joseph Jenkins |
| 1930 – 1932 | Leslie Markham |
| 1933 | Alfred Henry Hand |
| 1934 – 1941 | David Fitch |
| 1942 – 1943 | Lisle Freeman Spence |
| 1944 – 1948 | Francis Joseph Henry Allen |
| 1949 | Patros Athanas Tornaros |
| 1950 – 1956 | William Leslie Chapman |
| 1957 | Bernard Noel Fowler |
| 1958 – 1959 | Leo Joseph Spies |
Photographs of Mayors from 1900 – 1959
Photographs of Mayors from 1960 – 2000
Photographs of Mayors from 2001 –
List of Mayors 1960 –